What Happens After Your Asylum Application is Denied

What Happens After Your Asylum Application is Denied

Asylum serves as a crucial refuge for those fleeing persecution and danger. However, only some asylum applications yield a favorable outcome. This article delves into what transpires when an asylum application is denied and the avenues available for recourse.


The Asylum Application Process

An asylum application – in a significantly simplified form – entails a narrative of persecution or fear, supporting documents, and an interview with an asylum officer. Decisions may take time and depend on the case details, the claim’s credibility, and the adjudicating officer’s discretion.


Immediate Aftermath of Denied Asylum

Denying an asylum application can have immediate and significant impacts on an individual’s immigration status. Here are some key points to understand:

  • Notice to Appear: Upon denial of the asylum application, an asylum seeker is typically issued a Notice to Appear before an immigration court. This marks the initiation of removal proceedings.
  • Loss of Status: If an asylum seeker does not have another valid immigration status (e.g., a nonimmigrant visa), the denied asylum application means they are likely in the U.S. without legal status, which can complicate their immigration situation.
  • Bar on Reapplication (rare): In some cases, depending on the reason for denial, an asylum seeker may be barred from reapplying for asylum.

These immediate effects underscore the seriousness of a denied asylum application and the importance of understanding one’s rights and potential next steps.


Referral to Immigration Court

When an affirmative asylum application is denied, the case is typically referred to the Immigration Court. While a referral to the Immigration Court always means that you are placed in Removal Proceedings, it’s another opportunity to convince your Immigration Judge that you merit an asylum grant. Don’t waste it! Here’s what that process may involve:

  • Notice to Appear: With a denial, you’ll receive a Notice to Appear (NTA) before an immigration judge. This is essentially a summons to the Immigration Court to initiate removal proceedings.
  • Role of the Immigration Court: The Immigration Court, under the Executive Office for Immigration Review (EOIR), provides another opportunity to argue your case. Here, you will present your case to an immigration judge instead of an asylum officer.
  • New Evidence and Testimonies: The court process allows you to present new evidence or witnesses to strengthen your case. This can include new testimonies, updated country conditions, or other evidence bolsters your asylum claim’s credibility and urgency.

Navigating this part of the process can be complex. It is advised to seek legal representation to ensure all procedural requirements are met and the strongest case is presented.


Appealing a Denial from Immigration Court

If the immigration judge renders an unfavorable decision, it’s not the end of the road. You have the right to appeal the decision, and here’s how that process unfolds:

  • Filing an Appeal: The appeal should be lodged with the Board of Immigration Appeals (BIA), an administrative body that reviews decisions made by immigration judges. The appeal must present reasons why the judge’s decision was incorrect, either in fact or law.
  • 30-Day Window: It’s crucial to note that the appeal must be filed within 30 days of the immigration judge’s decision. An appeal filed after this period might not be considered, bearing specific exceptions.
  • Possible Outcomes: The BIA can affirm the immigration judge’s decision, reverse it, or send (remand) the case to the immigration judge for further proceedings. In some cases, the BIA can also hear oral arguments from both parties before deciding.

The appeal process is complex and entails specific legal and procedural requirements. Thus, securing legal help is strongly recommended to navigate this challenging phase.


Further Legal Recourses after a BIA Denial

A denial from the Board of Immigration Appeals (BIA) may seem disheartening, but it doesn’t necessarily mark the end of the legal journey. Here are your options after a BIA denial:

  • Federal Circuit Court of Appeals: If the BIA dismisses your appeal, you can take your case to the Federal Circuit Court of Appeals. This court is a higher judicial authority and has the power to review decisions made by the BIA.
  • U.S. Supreme Court: Although rare, it’s possible to escalate your case to the U.S. Supreme Court, the highest judicial authority in the country. This typically occurs if your case presents a novel and significant question of law.

These steps, while available, can be both time-consuming and complex. Legal representation is highly advisable when exploring these further legal recourses to ensure the best possible advocacy for your case.


Deportation Risks

Deportation looms large if all avenues of appeal fail or if no appeals are submitted on time. In such cases, the individual is usually ordered to leave the U.S. However, certain forms of relief from removal may be available.


A Denied Asylum Claim by the Asylum Office: Not the End, But a New Beginning

A denied asylum application might be a setback, but it’s far from the end of the road. From presenting your case afresh in the Immigration Court to appealing the decision at multiple levels, numerous legal avenues exist before all remedies are exhausted.

However, each step in this journey is fraught with legal nuances and procedural intricacies. It is, therefore, crucial to engage professional legal assistance to navigate this complex landscape. Immigration professionals and legal advisers can provide valuable advice tailored to your circumstances and potentially open doors you may not know.

Remember, the end of one phase often signals the beginning of another. A denial, while disheartening, can also set the stage for a more robust presentation of your claim, taking you one step closer to the sanctuary you seek.

If you have any questions about Immigration Laws, call us at 646-859-0205 to schedule a consultation. You can also email us at: info@spektorlawgroup.com or write to us via our Contact Page.

We will schedule you for a consultation over the phone or via video, and your consultation WILL be with one of our lawyers, guaranteed!

Talk to us today! You’ll be glad you did.

DISCLAIMER: This information is for reference only and might vary depending on your situation. Please always consult your lawyer for legal matters.

How to Get a Work Visa in the US
Immigration

How to Get a Work Visa in the US

The allure of working in the United States attracts countless individuals globally due to its thriving job market and diverse opportunities. Obtaining a US Work Visa is

Read More »